Chief suspect in Natalee Holloway disappearance pleads not guilty

Dutch citizen Joran van der Sloot is driven in a police vehicle from the Ancon I maximum-security prison, outskirts of Lima, Peru, Thursday, June 8, 2023. The main suspect in the unsolved 2005 disappearance of American student Natalee Holloway on the Caribbean island of Aruba is expected to be extradited Thursday from Peru to the United States. (AP Photo/Martin Mejia)

(Martin Mejia / Associated Press)

Chief suspect in Natalee Holloway disappearance pleads not guilty

June 9, 2023

Joran van der Sloot, the chief suspect in the 2005 disappearance of Natalee Holloway, pleaded not guilty Friday to federal charges that he tried to extort money from the missing teens mother in exchange for revealing the location of

her Natalee’s


Van der Sloot, 35, was extradited to the United States on Thursday from Peru, where he is serving a 28-year prison sentence after confessing to killing a Peruvian woman. He was arraigned in Birmingham, not far from the suburb where Holloway grew up, in his first court appearance in the case.

Natalees mother, Beth Holloway, watched the brief proceeding from the third row of the courtroom. She stared occasionally at

v V

an der Sloot but showed no obvious emotion.

For 18 years, I have lived with the unbearable pain of Natalees loss, she said in a statement Thursday. Each day has been filled with unanswered questions and a longing for justice that has eluded us at every turn. But today … I am hopeful that some small semblance of justice may finally be realized.

Main suspect in Natalee Holloway disappearance arrives in U.S. from Peru to face charges

Afterward, she hugged friends who had come to offer their support along with Natalees father and brother. She declined to comment to reporters outside the courthouse.

Shackled and wearing jeans and a white T-shirt,


Van der Sloot declined to use a Dutch interpreter offered to him at Fridays arraignment. He sat beside his court-appointed attorney, Kevin Butler, who entered the not guilty pleas on his behalf.

Van der Sloot is charged with one count each of extortion and wire fraud the only charges to have ever linked the Dutch citizen to Holloways disappearance on the Caribbean island of Aruba.

Natalee Holloway, 18, was on a high school graduation trip with classmates in Aruba when she vanished in 2005. She was last seen leaving a bar with


Van der Sloot, who was a student at an international school on the island. Van der Sloot was identified as a main suspect and detained weeks later for questioning, along with two Surinamese brothers, but no charges were filed in the case.

Suspect in Natalee Holloway’s 2005 disappearance to be extradited from Peru to U.S.

A judge declared Holloway dead, but her body has never been found.

The mysterious disappearance sparked years of news coverage and countless true-crime podcasts.

U.S. prosecutors say that in 2010,


Van der Sloot reached out to Beth Holloway, seeking $250,000 to lead her to the young woman’s body and reveal the circumstances of her death. A grand jury indicted him that year.

In 2012,


Van der Sloot pleaded guilty in Peru to killing 21-year-old Stephany Flores, a business student from a prominent Peruvian family. She was killed in 2010 five years to the day after Holloways disappearance.

Van der Sloot married a Peruvian woman in July 2014 in a ceremony at a maximum-security prison. He was shuffled between prisons in response to reports he enjoyed privileges like television, internet access and a cellphone, and accusations he threatened to kill a warden.

In reversal, suspect in Natalee Holloway’s disappearance will fight extradition to U.S.

A 2001 treaty between Peru and the U.S. allows a suspect to be temporarily extradited to face trial in the other country. Van der Sloots attorney, Mximo Altez, initially indicated his client would not challenge his extradition but that changed Monday when he filed a writ of habeas corpus. A judge ruled against


Van der Sloot the following day.

Peru has agreed to let


Van der Sloot remain in U.S. custody until the Alabama case is concluded, including any appeal if he is convicted, according to a resolution published in Perus federal register. U.S. authorities agree to return him to Peru’s custody after that, the resolution states.

Van der Sloot’s arrival at the Birmingham courthouse

, about 10 miles (16 kilometers) from Mountain Brook High School,

was something of a day of reckoning for a state and a city that blames him for Holloways disappearance.

It made me sick. I gasped, but Im so grateful that hes here, said Cindy Rysedorph, a friend of the Holloway family, as she described her first glimpse of


Van der Sloot in the courtroom.

Were not trying him for murder which we know he committed, she said. Were trying him for the extortion. But yeah, its progress.